Practical advice from a local plumberS R Francis • Bromley & surrounding areas
SR Francis flame and water drop logoS R FrancisPLUMBING & HEATINGmaintaining the flow of H₂O
Which? Trusted TraderTrustATrader
← All Homeowner Hints
Homeowner Hint #8

Why Does My Toilet Leak Only When I Flush It?

If your toilet only leaks when you flush it, that narrows the problem down considerably.

In most cases, the water is escaping from one of two places:

The pan connectorThis seals the toilet’s waste outlet to the soil pipe at the back.
The flush-water connection above itThat means the flush-pipe seal on a concealed toilet, or the close-coupling seal where a cistern sits directly on the pan.

What Type of Toilet Have You Got?

The same two connections do the work on every toilet, but the way you reach and see them depends on the toilet type.

Close-coupled

Close-coupled toilet with the cistern fitted directly onto the pan
Cutaway close-coupled toilet showing the close-coupling seal between the cistern and pan

Close-coupling seal between the cistern and pan

The cistern sits directly on the pan. A flush-only leak can come from the close-coupling seal between them or from the pan connector behind the toilet.

Back-to-wall

Back-to-wall toilet pan with the cistern concealed in the furniture behind it
Semi-transparent back-to-wall toilet showing the smaller flush-pipe connection above the larger waste and pan-connector connection

Back-to-wall toilet with both concealed connections visible

The pan sits against the wall or furniture and the cistern is concealed. Both the flush-pipe and waste connections are hidden behind it.

Wall-hung

Wall-hung toilet pan mounted above the floor with a concealed cistern
Labelled semi-transparent wall-hung toilet showing the smaller flush-pipe connection above the larger pan-connector and waste connection

Wall-hung toilet with its concealed connections visible

The pan is fixed to a frame above the floor. The same two water and waste connections are behind it, but the pan usually has to be removed to inspect them properly.

See the three toilet types and common faults on the SR Francis Toilet Repairs page →

Start With Having a Look

The first thing I do is a visual check. Sometimes the source is blatant: there is still water sitting around the failed connection, or staining shows exactly where it has been running.

1. Look before flushingCheck behind and around the base for standing water, staining or obvious damage.
2. Watch one flushLook behind the toilet while somebody flushes it.
3. Check high and lowSee whether the water starts at the upper flush connection or lower down at the pan connector.

A modern dual-flush toilet usually releases roughly three or six litres. That is a fair amount of water, so if the connections are visible, an active flush leak is normally not difficult to spot.

Dripping Water Doesn’t Go Up

In 30 years, I have never managed to get dripping water to go up. That simple fact is useful here.

If you flush the toilet and find water sitting on top of the pan connector, the connector below cannot have put it there. The leak must be starting higher up, which points to the flush-pipe seal or the close-coupling seal.

If the top of the pan connector stays dry but water appears from the connector itself or below it during the flush, the pan connector or its seal becomes the more likely source.

Follow the water back to the highest wet point. The place where the puddle ends up is not always the place where the leak started.

What About a Concealed or Wall-Hung Toilet?

Back-to-wall and wall-hung toilets can be more awkward because the important connections are hidden. If there is useful access from above or through a removable panel, a phone can sometimes help: position it safely behind the pan, record while the toilet is flushed, then review the video for the first sign of water.

If the toilet is fitted tightly against the wall or furniture, there may be no honest way to inspect the seals from outside. If it is leaking, the pan has to come out to be repaired. You cannot leave it leaking. Take it out, have a proper look and see exactly what you are dealing with.

Once it is out, the cause is often obvious. There may be staining down the back of the pan, a distorted flush-pipe seal, or a pan connector that is split, poorly fitted or badly deteriorated. I can show the customer the staining or damage and exactly where the water has been escaping. There is no guesswork.

Do not force a concealed panel or try to pull a fixed pan away from the wall. Removing and refitting it without damaging the sanitaryware or connections is a job for a plumber.

Should I Keep Using the Toilet?

Ideally, stop using it until the leak has been repaired. Every flush sends more water through the failed seal, and that water can damage flooring, furniture or the ceiling below.

But we live in the real world. If it is the only toilet in the house, I understand that people may have to use it before a plumber can get there.

If you cannot avoid using it, use it as little as possible, contain and dry any escaped water immediately, and arrange the repair. If the leak is substantial, water is reaching electrics, or it is damaging the room below, stop using the toilet.

Toilet Leaking When Flushed in Bromley?

Call or WhatsApp Steve

Get in touch and I’ll ask a few questions to narrow down where the water is coming from:

  • Does it leak only during the flush?
  • Is the water appearing high up or around the pan connector?
  • Is it close-coupled, back-to-wall or wall-hung?
  • Can you safely get a short video while it flushes?

If the connections are hidden or the pan needs to come out, we can arrange a visit and repair it properly.

For other repairs around the home, see SR Francis plumbing services in Bromley.

SR Francis Plumbing and HeatingBusiness operating address (no walk-in premises): 19 Holmcroft Way, Bromley BR2 8ADCall 07794 814961 · WhatsApp Steve